Bio-banking: digitalization of the healthcare market
Panacea or hype?
31 July 2020
In the second of a series of short articles looking at the major challenges of the digitalization of the European healthcare market, this article focuss on the challenges of data protection in bio-banking - with a special view to Germany
Bio-banks represent a particular challenge in terms of data protection. Bio-banks are collections of samples of human body substances such as tissue, blood, urine or saliva, which are linked to personal data and socio-demographic information about individual persons.
In Germany, there are about 130 bio-banks to date which are operated by both public and private institutions. In contrast to some other EU Member States, the use of bio-material for research in Germany is currently not separately regulated under data protection law. Rather, the examination of genetic samples and data for research purposes has even been expressly excluded from the scope of application of the Act on Genetic Testing of Human Beings 2009 ('GenDG'). Only a few state hospital laws (e.g. in Hamburg) specify regulations on the collection of bio-samples and data.
The other existing international guidelines and recommendations, such as the Recommendation Rec(2006)4 of the Council of Europe on Research on Biological Materials of Human Origin or the OECD Guidelines for Biobanks and Genetic Research Databases of 2009 or the Guide for Research Ethics Committee Members issued by the Steering Committee of the Council of Europe, are all legally non-binding.
Since the amount of data accumulated in bio-banks is constantly growing and the associated possibilities for misuse are thus increasing, appropriate binding regulations are needed.
This is all the more true given that data from bio-banks are frequently transferred across borders. A key question that must be taken into account in legal regulation is, among other things, whether bio-samples can be anonymised at all given that genetic information is always retained when they are stored. Further, anonymisation is frequently not compatible with the research purpose underlying the storage of bio-data, for example when donors are to be contacted again.
Read the first article in this series: The digitalization of the healthcare market - data collection, processing and retention
Read Gunnar's detailed sector-specific contributions on this subject at dataguidance.com.